Flickr: a very disturbing message
By glazou on Tuesday 21 June 2005, 09:26 - General - Permalink
I have just received the following message from Flickr:
The Flickr team has up and moved this week to Californ-i-a and has been singing Beach Boys songs non-stop since arrival. And you're moving too! We're moving each and every pixel, bit, and byte, all your data, lock, stock, and barrel, from our humble server shack in Canada to our new server palace in the U.S. of A! This process will begin during the week of June 28 and will result in speediness, stableness, and happiness. For more information, please visit the FAQ about the data center move. http://www.flickr.com/help.gne#94 Thank you, Flickreebies, for making Flickr such a wonderful place to share, connect, and befriend. We love you! (In an entirely non-creepy way.) - The Flickroobies
I find it extremely disturbing because the governing law of the data stored in Flickr servers changes suddenly, and the users only get a "by the way, we move" message; this is far from what I would expect from a serious and customer-centric online service. It also means user profiles data (besides photos) kept by Flickr are now governed by US law instead of Canadian law, and that makes a BIG difference. At least for me.

Comments
As far as I know your data stays property of the Canadian company Ludicorp until you accept the new US Yahoo agreement. Therefore, Canadian law still applies to your data.
To educate myself about the differences between the laws, I googled:
"software license" canada USA
and got over 36,000 hits. Wow. Do you have a favorite website you would recommend as a nice summary of the differences between the laws?
Thanks!
- Dan Ashley
I believe as soon as Yahoo agreed to purchase them, they became bound to US law. Being in canada just means they were *also* bound to US law.
For example, if I have some illegal content, and use a server in China (where it's legal). I'm still bound to US law. They can still arrest me, charge me, etc. etc. It doesn't matter what China thinks.
So the switch in a legal sense happened a few months ago. This is just a server move.
Just deleted my flickr account in order to fix the "glitch"